Capitalist Review

Financial Products Reviewed

Passive vs Active Investment Management (Mutual Funds vs ETFs)

October 29, 2015 by CapitalistReview Leave a Comment

It seems like a never-ending discussion: mutual funds vs ETFs, or active versus passive investing. Fund managers claim that due to a savvy investment strategy, they are able to cherry pick and compose a portfolio with for the larger part winning stocks. In the long run, this should lead to a clear outperformance. On the other side, backed by academic literature, ETF investors claim that beating the market is unrealistic and that passive index trackers are all an investor need. The recent S&P Indices Versus Active Funds (SPIVA) Europe Scorecard by index builder S&P Dow Jones Indices (SPDJI) proves that the latter group may have it right, although the debate will probably continue.

SPIVA Scorecards were introduced in 2002 to make a substantial contribution in the active vs. passive debate. The best way to contribute is by providing data which are easily to understand. The SPIVA Euro Scorecard offers an insight in the performance of European equity funds in various classes (all data were based on June 30, 2015). Interestingly, there’s a significant difference in the amount of funds able to beat the market on a one-year basis. Nevertheless, the picture is not in favor for active fund managers. Whereas 55% of fund managers with a Europe Equity mandate fails to deliver, almost 84% of managers with an US Equity mandate is not able to beat the broad S&P 500 Index. According to SPDJI, there may be a simple explanation: during the first half of 2015 the US market was largely moving sideward, where Europe was confronted with the Greek crisis. The argument goes that active managers can show their real ability in times of stress. However the argument doesn’t hold for emerging markets, which showed a very volatile 12-months period, but fund managers still largely lagging their benchmark.

As years go by, a potential advantage for active managers seem to fade further. Shocking fact: over 98% over European fund managers with an US Equity mandate fails to beat the market. A large part may be explained by costs. Expense ratios for European equity funds are well above their US counterpart, let alone ETFs. Charging 1-2% a year makes a significant difference in yield over a 10-year timespan. The score for Emerging Markets Equity is also poor (97% of underperforming managers). This may indicate that the generally higher fees for this type of funds don’t make up for special expertise in emerging markets. Due to country risk and often corporate governance challenges, one could argue there’s a good case to bring in a fund manager with specific knowledge of local markets. But apparently only a few managers are worth the money. Only one positive note: when focusing on a single country, the added value of an active approach seems to increase. The German and France Equity mandates show better rates than those of broader investment mandates. However, 83-86% unable to beat the index over a period of 10-years is rather poor.

Not surprisingly, a large number of funds is unable to survive over a 10-year time span. The SPIVA-study notes that roughly 50% of European equity funds are either liquidated or merged over the past 10 years. With these figures, investors have a solid rationale for passive investment. Although one should realize that due to yearly costs, an ETF will also fail to beat the benchmark. However, with costs only a fraction (0.05-0.15% a year), the underperformance will be likely far less than when investing in an actively managed mutual fund. So let’s get passive!

 

Contents hide
1 Share this:
2 Related

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

India’s increasing efforts to tilt Africa toward its economic and political axis
Valeant: The Trouble With Following Famous Investors

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Posts

  • Jet Blue Mastercard Activate and Review (Barclaycardus Activate Online)
    Jet Blue Mastercard Activate and Review (Barclaycardus Activate Online)
  • Best Buy Account Credit Card Login, Activation, & Review
    Best Buy Account Credit Card Login, Activation, & Review
  • GetMyOffer.CapitalOne.com - Card Application for 2022
    GetMyOffer.CapitalOne.com - Card Application for 2022
  • www.mercurycards.com/activate - Login to Activate Your Mercury Mastercard
    www.mercurycards.com/activate - Login to Activate Your Mercury Mastercard
  • AmericanExpress.com Confirm Card (2022 AMEX Card Review)
    AmericanExpress.com Confirm Card (2022 AMEX Card Review)
  • www.AspireCreditCard.com Pre-Approved/Acceptance Code (2022)
    www.AspireCreditCard.com Pre-Approved/Acceptance Code (2022)
  • Upstart.com My Offer Code, Refinance, & Reviews
    Upstart.com My Offer Code, Refinance, & Reviews
  • FirstNationalCC Apply (Card Review & App - Updated 2022)
    FirstNationalCC Apply (Card Review & App - Updated 2022)
  • www.wellsfargo.com/myoffer reservation number - Respond to Mail Offer
    www.wellsfargo.com/myoffer reservation number - Respond to Mail Offer
  • Valero.com/creditcard payment - Valero Fleet Login/Review
    Valero.com/creditcard payment - Valero Fleet Login/Review




Pages

  • About Capitalist Review
  • Affiliate Policy
  • Capitalist Review
  • CapitalistReview Merch
  • CapitalistReview Privacy Policy
  • CapitalistReview Terms of Use
  • CapitalistReview.com
  • Contact
  • Sponsored, Guest Post, and Advertising

Categories

  • Credit Cards
  • Investing
  • Banking
  • Loans
  • Mortgage
  • Capital One Credit Card
  • SoFi Student Loans

Recent Posts

  • JJillCard.com: Make a Payment & Update Account
  • GetMyOffer.CapitalOne.com – Card Application for 2022
  • OpenSkyCC.com/Activate: MyAccount Online Account Activation
  • Exxon Mobil Credit Card Login, Application, & Review
  • Can You Use a Walmart Credit Card at Sam’s Club? (FAQ)

Navigation

Capitalist Review Sitemap

Contact Us

Popular

Jetbluemastercard.com/Activate

mercurycards.com/activate

www.barclaysus.com/activate

Recent Posts

  • JJillCard.com: Make a Payment & Update Account
  • GetMyOffer.CapitalOne.com – Card Application for 2022
  • OpenSkyCC.com/Activate: MyAccount Online Account Activation
  • Exxon Mobil Credit Card Login, Application, & Review
  • Can You Use a Walmart Credit Card at Sam’s Club? (FAQ)

RSS Capitalist Review

  • JJillCard.com: Make a Payment & Update Account May 25, 2022
    JJill Card Payment You can pay your J. Jill credit card in a variety of different forms, the easiest being online. In order to pay your bill online please visit https://d.comenity.net/ac/jjill/public/home and click on the “sign-in” tab. This will allow you to access your account homepage. Please note those who are new to the card […]
    CapitalistReview
  • GetMyOffer.CapitalOne.com – Card Application for 2022 May 24, 2022
    Get My Offer From Capital One (Quick Summary) A credit card offer from Capital One Almost always arrives by US Mail in the form of a promotional application Intended for consumers with a good to great credit score If you receive this offer you should be happy as you have a great credit score The […]
    CapitalistReview
  • OpenSkyCC.com/Activate: MyAccount Online Account Activation May 22, 2022
    Activate an OpenSky credit card online Simply rev up the old PC and head on over to www.openskycc.com/activate and follow the on-screen instructions. Activation will take about 5 minutes to complete. Please note in order to obtain the OpenSky credit card you must be 18 years of age or older and a legal resident of […]
    CapitalistReview
  • Exxon Mobil Credit Card Login, Application, & Review May 22, 2022
    Exxon Mobil Credit Card Login If you are an Exxon Mobil credit card customer and are looking to take your credit card online please visit citiretailservices.citibankonline.com and follow the on-screen prompts. You must provide an email address, Alternative site logins include exxonmobilcard.com login and https://citiretailservices.citibankonline.com. Please note you must be 18 years of age or […]
    CapitalistReview
  • Can You Use a Walmart Credit Card at Sam’s Club? (FAQ) May 22, 2022
    Can you use a Walmart credit card at Sam’s club? Walmart issues two credit cards: Walmart MasterCard and the Walmart Rewards Card. You must be 18 years of age or older and a legal resident of the United States. Both Walmart credit cards can be used at Sam’s Club. Visit walmart.capitalone.com to learn more about […]
    CapitalistReview

You can trust the integrity of our balanced, independent financial advice provided by Capitaliat Review. CR may, however, receive compensation from the issuers of some products mentioned in these articles. Opinions, reviews, analysis, advice, and thoughts are the author’s alone and his/her alone only. This content has not been provided by, reviewed, approved or endorsed by any advertiser, unless otherwise noted.

pages

  • About Capitalist Review
  • Affiliate Policy
  • Best Credit Cards of 2016
  • Capitalist Review
  • CapitalistReview Merch
  • CapitalistReview Privacy Policy
  • CapitalistReview Terms of Use
  • CapitalistReview.com
  • Contact
  • IndigoCard.com Apply – Indigo Platinum MasterCard Review
  • Sofi.com/Refinance1: Pre-Selected Refinance Promotional Offer Worth It?
  • Sponsored, Guest Post, and Advertising
  • Student.DRBank.com/BigSavings – Refinance Student Loan with DRB?
  • www.Betterment.com/Start – 5 Reasons to Invest with Betterment
  • www.cashnetusa.com/approved – Prequalified Loan Offer
  • www.SaveWithProsper.com – Prosper Loan Review for Borrowers
  • www.sofi.com reviews – SoFi Review and Sign Up Bonus
  • www.trysofi.com – Student Loan Refinancing From SoFi Worth It?
  • www.upstart.com/myoffer – Upstart Loan Application
  • Best Credit Cards
  • Best Credit Cards For Foodies
  • Coronavirus Home Refi?

© 2016–2022 Capitalist Review